One of the unfortunate problems for Progressives who want to find a way to justify their newfound love and respect for the Palestinian people in Gaza in general and the radical Islamic terrorist organization Hamas in the specific has been that most of these Progressive types live lives that would... not be looked upon kindly by the people and government of Gaza, to say the least. People who are in a homosexual relationship in particular face the very real prospect of execution in Gaza, regardless of how faithful to the causes of Hamas they may have been. So clearly some equivocation is in order to sync up support for a state that has a habit of out-of-hand executing people who look, think, and act like you... and when you're looking to equivocate a tried-and-true method is good 'ol 'whataboutism', although that comes with the unfortunate downside of making you look like an idiot if you don't know what you're doing while trying to pull it off.
In this vein it's hard to think of any more ham-handed and idiotic attempt to 'whatabout' the question of being a homosexual supporting Hamas by claiming that really, when you think about it, isn't the American South really just as bad? But here we go taking this argument out for a test drive anyways, it seems.
my lover and i would likely find it difficult to walk hand in hand in the bible belt. do i think mississippi should be bombed to smithereens? no https://t.co/o5w3Q0OTCB
— matt (@mattxiv) May 6, 2024
In Gaza there have long been well documented reports of how men found engaging in homosexual acts are dealt with, from the aforementioned straight up executions to more pleasant options like being repeatedly kidnapped off the street, imprisoned, tortured, and beaten. Just like happens every day all over the South, right?
Of course there were some who responded who were perfectly willing to go along with this absurd argument.
I can literally be killed and my murder can get off the hook due to a technicality.... I live in Texas
— noah FREE PALESTINE🇵🇸🇵🇸 (@ItBoyYeonjunnie) May 6, 2024
Overlooking the general dumbness of the statement itself, a pretty major difference here would be that unlike in Texas it would in fact be the current government doing the murdering in Gaza... which seems like a pretty big difference, right? It's not just 'getting off on a technicality' (imagine having a legal system that requires due process, right?), it's a summary execution by the State. Good lord.
Recommended
Of course in the end these tend to be bloodthirsty folk in the Hamas boosters club, so they're thinking maybe this guys original hesitancy to bomb Mississippi might be misplaced.
Let's not rule out bombing Mississippi
— Caveman (@caveman984) May 6, 2024
He's just kidding of course, we're sure of it.
Most, as it turns out, were not as supportive of the overall thesis of the post.
No you don't
— ᵞⁱᵏᵉˢ (@TrueBeefSupreme) May 6, 2024
You can walk around the Bible belt just fine you drama queen
This is simply not true.
— GiraffinMeCrazy (@GiraffinC) May 6, 2024
It is remarkably silly to make this comparison. Just shows how absurdly ignorant you actually are about the ME.
— MatthewOBrien (@ThatMattOBrien) May 6, 2024
Yeah, almost none of these people have any idea what life is actually like for the people they support because of the barbaric rulers these people also support. It's a trendy cause so they're all for it despite having almost no understanding of what exactly it is they're supporting.
"likely find it difficult" is far different from "absolutely would be killed for"
— Tarellion (@tarellion) May 6, 2024
Not that I expect you to comprehend such a simple distinction.
You'd still be way safer than in palestine.
— Tim Arsenault (@titanictimmah) May 6, 2024
This is one of the most pathetic and lazy false equivalencies I've seen.
— A True Liberal 🏳️🌈 (@MInthenow70635) May 6, 2024
You can keep trying but there is no justification for defending Hamas.
There's no justification for it but that won't stop these weirdos from keeping to try them! Higher order reasoning was never their strong suit.
Supporting Hamas, who aims to instill sharia on all the land through violence, means you support the brutal and deadly oppression of LGBT, both Israeli and Palestinian.
— JM-BR (@JesseMBRFGC) May 6, 2024
It's not about you - it's about who you are throwing under the bus.
Would you be thrown off a high rise building in 🇺🇸 for being gay? No. In Gaza yes.
— nostitosti (@NostiTosti) May 6, 2024
Don’t minimise the truth about the place & people. A very different culture. We do not all think the same. Foolish to think otherwise
This is facetious hyperbole and it’s damaging.
— Dave Delivers (@jeffersonianguy) May 6, 2024
Yes and yes.
Thanks for letting us know you’re as ignorant about America as you are Gaza. https://t.co/R5D5u2znhm
— Jonathan Greenberg (@JGreenbergSez) May 6, 2024
Leftism is the politics of people who are completely out of touch with reality. https://t.co/cSIMvEK22R
— Alexander Andreas Bauer (@themostbanned) May 6, 2024
Gay people STOP comparing the American south to the islamist controlled Middle East where gays are beheaded as rule of law challenge: Impossible https://t.co/lpwpYpzfR7
— Mary Wu (@MaryWuWho) May 6, 2024
Cognitive dissonance is a hell of a thing.
It seems that it's an old-fashioned outlook to expect people to have thought through their beliefs and their convictions on who and what they support, to maintain some level of consistency of logic in these things. Certainly on the left that sort of thinking seems to have fallen out of favor, if it was ever in favor on the left. For our part we'll say that we hope that this guy never finds himself actually in Gaza to get a good close look at how they'd react to him being ostentatiously gay in that part of the world... because despite our differences we'd prefer to not see him dead. It's a sentiment that may not be reciprocated.
Join the conversation as a VIP Member